Brewer, D. D., Potterat, J. J., Muth, S. Q., & Brody, S. (2009). Raising the standard of evidence for determining modes of HIV transmission. PloS One.

Raising the standard of evidence for determining modes of HIV transmission

Raising the standard of evidence for determining modes of HIV transmission

Posted by Devon Brewer on 21 May 2009 at 05:15 GMT

Jafa and colleagues (1)⁠ report one of the strongest investigations of HIV transmission modes in adults yet. Their work substantially lifts the evidentiary bar for identifying modes of HIV transmission. Particular strengths of their investigation include focus on incident infection, multiple modes of transmission, time and place of exposures, contact tracing, network representation, and DNA sequencing HIV variants in infected persons.

Despite these considerable strengths, there are several important gaps in their investigation. We are puzzled that full data on the networks of sex, injection, and tattooing contacts were neither detailed nor related to variation in cases' HIV DNA sequences. Also, insights about transmission routes were significantly limited because the contacts (sexual, injection, and tattooing) of HIV seroconverters who reported sex while in prison were not elicited and traced. In addition, it is unclear what types of contact were included in the measured sexual exposures (anal, oral, and/or manual?), drug injection exposures (e.g., shared needles/syringes, other shared injection paraphernalia, syringe-mediated drug sharing, administering injections to others, receiving injections from others, and/or injecting together?), and tattooing exposures (e.g., shared implements, shared ink, receiving a tattoo from another, giving a tattoo to another, and/or tattooed at same time/place as another?). Depending on the scope of the measured exposures, associations with HIV infection may have been underestimated. Furthermore, it is concerning that other blood exposures in prison (e.g., from fights, piercing, shared razors, etc.) and the contacts involved in such exposures were not assessed.

Some of Jafa and colleagues' interpretations of their results do not correspond with the actual evidence reported. The authors minimize the potential importance of tattooing in the spread of HIV because “there is no documented case of HIV transmission via tattooing to date.” Not only does the evidence they present suggest a significant role for tattooing, but the positive association between tattooing (particularly in prison settings) and HIV infection is very well-established (2-19)⁠, and tattooing in prisons is especially unhygienic (20-22)⁠. In most prior studies, the relationship between tattooing and HIV infection was independent of other blood and sexual exposures. Curiously, the authors also attribute HIV infections to sexual exposures when cases had both sexual and blood (illicit drug injection and/or tattooing) exposures. Instead, the authors' data suggest that both sexual and blood (tattooing and drug injection) exposures were involved in HIV transmission, with the relative importance of specific modes unable to be distilled with the research design implemented.

To determine HIV transmission modes with confidence, it is necessary to assess blood and sexual exposures comprehensively for incident cases and controls, trace their corresponding contacts, and sequence infected persons’ HIV isolates (23; 24)⁠. Investigations that build on the authors' trailblazing work and employ the full research design we describe are sorely needed in other populations and settings, such as African-American women (25)⁠ and throughout sub-Saharan Africa, Asia, and the Caribbean. We can only hope that health ministries and HIV researchers everywhere will assign high priority to such fundamental investigations.

Devon D. Brewer, Interdisciplinary Scientific Research
John J. Potterat, independent consultant, Colorado Springs
Stephen Q. Muth, Quintus-ential Solutions
Stuart Brody, University of the West of Scotland

1. Jafa K, McElroy P, Fitzpatrick L, Borkowf CB, MacGowan R, Margolis A, Robbins K, Youngpairoj AS, Stratford D, Greenberg A. HIV transmission in a state prison system, 1988-2005. PLoS ONE. 2009;4(5):e5416.

2. Dandona L, Dandona R, Kumar GA, Reddy GB, Ameer MA, Ahmed GM, Ramgopal SP, Akbar M, Sudha T, Lakshmi V. Risk factors associated with HIV in a population-based study in Andhra Pradesh state of India. Int J Epidemiol. 2008;37(6):1274-1286.

3. Cunha L, Plouzeau C, Ingrand P, Gudo JPS, Ingrand I, Mondlane J, Beauchant M, Agius G. Use of replacement blood donors to study the epidemiology of major blood-borne viruses in the general population of Maputo, Mozambique. J Med Virol. 2007;79(12):1832-1840.

4. Mattson CL, Bailey RC, Agot K, Ndinya-Achola JO, Moses S. A nested case-control study of sexual practices and risk factors for prevalent HIV-1 infection among young men in Kisumu, Kenya. Sex Transm Dis. 2007;34(10):731-6.

5. Pourahmad M, Javady A, Karimi I, Ataei B, Kassaeian N. Seroprevalence of and risk factors associated with hepatitis B, hepatitis C, and human immunodeficiency virus among prisoners in Iran. Infect Dis Clin Prac. 2007;15(6):368-372.

6. Thaisri H, Lerwitworapong J, Vongsheree S, Sawanpanyalert P, Chadbanchachai C, Rojanawiwat A, Kongpromsook W, Paungtubtim W, Sri-ngam P, Jaisue R. HIV infection and risk factors among Bangkok prisoners, Thailand: a prospective cohort study. BMC Infect Dis. 2003;3(25).

7. Panda S, Kumar MS, Lokabiraman S, Jayashree K, Satagopan MC, Solomon S, Rao UA, Rangaiyan G, Flessenkaemper S, Grosskurth H, Gupte MD. Risk factors for HIV infection in injection drug users and evidence for onward transmission of HIV to their sexual partners in Chennai, India. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2005;39(1):9-15.

8. Beyrer C, Jittiwutikarn J, Teokul W, Razak MH, Suriyanon V, Srirak N, Vongchuk T, Tovanabutra S, Sripaipan T, Celentano DD. Drug use, increasing incarceration rates, and prison-associated HIV risks in Thailand. AIDS Behav. 2003;7(2):153-161.

9. Rahbar AR, Rooholamini S, Khoshnood K. Prevalence of HIV infection and other blood-borne infections in incarcerated and non-incarcerated injection drug users (IDUs) in Mashhad, Iran. Int J Drug Policy. 2004;15(2):151-155.

10. Rodrigues JJ, Mehendale SM, Shepherd ME, Divekar AD, Gangakhedkar RR, Quinn TC, Paranjape RS, Risbud AR, Brookmeyer RS, Gadkari DA. Risk factors for HIV infection in people attending clinics for sexually transmitted diseases in India. BMJ. 1995;311(7000):283-286.

11. Buavirat A, Page-Shafer K, Van Griensven GJP, Mandel JS, Evans J, Chuaratanaphong J, Chiamwongpat S, Sacks R, Moss A. Risk of prevalent HIV infection associated with incarceration among injecting drug users in Bangkok, Thailand: case-control study. BMJ. 2003;326(7384):308.

12. Pérez Agudo F, Alonso Moreno FJ, Urbina Torija J. Prevalencia de infección por el virus de la inmunodeficiencia humana tipo 1 y de Mycobacterium tuberculosis en una población reclusa entre los años 1.989 y 1.995. Med Clin (Barc). 1998;110(5):167.

13. Zamani S, Kihara M, Gouya MM, Vazirian M, Ono-Kihara M, Razzaghi EM, Ichikawa S. Prevalence of and factors associated with HIV-1 infection among drug users visiting treatment centers in Tehran, Iran. AIDS. 2005;19(7):709-16.

14. Motevalian SA, Farhoodi B, Motamedi M, Motevali Khamene M, Mohraz M, Rasoulinejad M, Jaafari S, Afshar P, Esmailie I, Mohseni L. Prevalence of HIV and risky behaviors among injecting drug users of a prison in Tehran. Abstract no. MOAC203, 4th IAS Conference on HIV Pathogenesis, Treatment and Prevention, Sydney, Australia, 2007.

15. Zhang GL, Wang N, Xu JJ, Pu Y, Ni WL, Lu L, Min XD, Ma YL, Ding GW, Fu ZH. Epidemiologic study on STD/HIV infections among tin mining workers in Gejiu, Yunnan province. Zhonghua yu fang yi xue za zhi [Chinese journal of preventive medicine]. 2007;41(4):285-289.

16. Laurent C, Bourgeois A, Mpoudi M, Butel C, Peeters M, Mpoudi-Ngolé E, Delaporte E. Commercial logging and HIV epidemic, rural equatorial Africa. Emerg Infect Dis. 2004;10(11):1953-1956.

17. Nishioka SA, Gyorkos TW, Joseph L, Collet JP, MacLean JD. Tattooing and transfusion-transmitted diseases in Brazil: a hospital-based cross-sectional matched study. Eur J Epidemiol. 2003;18(5):441-449.

18. Entz AT, Ruffolo VP, Chinveschakitvanich V, Soskolne V, Van Griensven GJP. HIV-1 prevalence, HIV-1 subtypes and risk factors among fishermen in the Gulf of Thailand and the Andaman Sea. AIDS. 2000;14(8):1027-1034.

19. Martín V, Caylà JA, Morís ML, Alonso LE, Pérez R, Sánchez VM. Evolución de la prevalencia de infección por virus de la inmunodeficiencia humana en población reclusa al ingreso en prisión durante el período 1991-1995. Rev Esp Salud Pública. 1997;71(3):269-280.

20. Akeke VA, Mokgatle M, Oguntibeju OO. Tattooing and risk of transmitting HIV in Quthing prison, Lesotho. Int J STD AIDS. 2007;18(5):363-364.

21. Goyer KC. HIV/AIDS in prison: problems, policies and potential. ISS Monograph Series, no. 79. Tshwane (Pretoria): Institute for Security Studies; 2003. Available from:

22. Frost L, Tchertkov V. Prisoner risk taking in the Russian Federation. AIDS Educ Prev. 2002;14(5 Suppl):7-23.

23. Brewer DD, Rothenberg RB, Potterat JJ, Brody S, Gisselquist D. HIV epidemiology in sub-Saharan Africa: rich in conjecture, poor in data. Int J STD AIDS. 2004;15(1):63-65.

24. Brewer DD, Hagan H, Sullivan DG, Muth SQ, Hough ES, Feuerborn NA, Gretch DR. Social structural and behavioral underpinnings of hyperendemic Hepatitis C virus transmission in drug injectors. J Infect Dis. 2006;194(6):764-772.

25. Potterat JJ, Brewer DD, Brody S. Blind spots in the epidemiology of HIV in black Americans. Int J STD AIDS. 2008;19(1):1-3.

No competing interests declared.

See all ongoing discussions on this article